If you are someone who travels a lot or simply can’t stand external noise then you definitely have heard about noise canceling vs noise isolating headphones. While they may sound like they do the exact same thing, the two types of headphones are definitely nothing alike.
When you’re at the store looking for noise canceling headphones you may often find products that come with “noise canceling” on the packaging even when they’re actually offering noise isolation. It can get really confusing. So, what exactly is going on? While both these types of headphones reduce noise, how they do it is very different.
Noise isolating headphones are capable of physically blocking ambient noise by physically sealing off external sounds against your ear. However, noise canceling headphones achieve the same result by electronically canceling the sound waves as they enter your ear.
Table of Contents
Noise Canceling Headphones come with dedicated microphones that detect incoming noise and create inverse waves which are directed at your ears. So, what do these inverse waves do you might ask?
Inverse Wave Technology
These inverse waves cancel out the ambient sound. If it sounds a little to complicated, let us help break it down for you. Imagine you are sitting in a noisy workplace. Assume the noise generated by the clickity clackity keyboards is a “+1” noise. Your headphones will detect the noise and generate a “-1” noise so it cuts off the noise of keyboards so you hear nothing but your favorite songs.
Not Perfect but Close
While this amazing technology might sound like a perfect way to cut off noise and enjoy nothing but the best of tunes, the technology is definitely not perfect. Noise canceling is great for cutting out lows and midrange noises. However, shrill noises are usually not cut off properly.
Do note that noise canceling headphones can’t just be powered by your phone or tablet. They come with batteries to power the mics and enable noise cancelation in both Quality is, of course, another major factor when it comes to the technology. The best noise canceling headphones money can buy will offer you astonishingly good noise cancelation while low-quality ones can actually have bad implementation of the technology and ruin your music experience.
The QuietComfort 35 II from Bose is simply one of the top wireless noise canceling headphones money can buy and they are priced well below what you’d expect to spend on high-end noise isolation headphones that run into the thousand-dollar mark in cases.
Bose is known for its high-end noise canceling features and you can expect nothing but the very best when it comes to the brand. Their noise cancelation is so great that it is the gold standard brand in the aviation industry and is trusted by professionals all over the world.
The headphones come with a cable so you can connect it directly to your media device if you run out of battery power as well. You get access to media controls, stellar battery life and amazing comfort all in one package.
- Three levels of world-class noise cancellation for better listening experience in any environment
- Alexa-enabled for voice access to music, information, and more
- Noise-rejecting dual-microphone system for clear sound and voice pick-up
The Backbeat Sense from Plantronics offers stunning aesthetics and solid audio output on a budget. It can work both wired and wirelessly thanks to the detachable cable and solid Bluetooth connectivity. The OpenMic feature allows you to hear background audio without requiring you to take your headphones off.
With 18 hours of battery backup and rich, detailed audio offered on a budget, Plantronics is offering a great value for money product. It is one of the best budget on-ear headphones you can get and its premium design and build quality definitely scores a few extra points for us.
- Consumer Alert: Most users do not need a license to operate this wireless microphone system. Nevertheless, operating this microphone system without a license is subject to certain restrictions: the system may not cause harmful interference; it must operate at a low power level (not in excess of 50 milliwatts); and it has no protection from interference received from any other device.
- Purchasers should also be aware that the FCC is currently evaluating use of wireless microphone systems, and these rules are subject to change. For more information, call the FCC at 1-888- CALL-FCC (TTY: 1-888-TELL-FCC) or visit the FCC's wireless microphone website at fcc.gov/cgb/wirelessmicrophones.
While the Bose QuietComfort 35 II edges past the Sony when it comes to noise cancelation quality, the WH-H900N offers many more features including voice assistant support that works with both Android and iOS devices.
The support for a large number of codecs and stellar battery life makes the Sony headphones a deal you should not pass up on if you’re out there looking for nothing but the very best.
- High-resolution Audio compatible
- Dsee HX Upscale compressed music to near high-resolution sound quality
- Digital noise cancelling and ambient sound mode let you control what you hear
Wired vs Wireless Noise Canceling Headphones
If you are looking to buy noise canceling headphones you will often run into the age-old dilemma of wired vs wireless noise canceling headphones. If you love listening to music while commuting and do not want wires to tangle around you all the time, a wireless pair of headphones will definitely get the job done.
However, if you simply work in a noisy environment and don’t really mind having a wire attached to your phone, tablet or laptop you can opt for a wired pair of noise canceling headphones. Do note that even wired noise canceling headphones require external power and you’ll need to keep recharging batteries to use the noise cancelation features.
Unlike noise canceling headphones, noise isolation headphones are usually of the on-ear variant and have their cups designed to prevent the annoying external sounds from getting in. They are good enough for muffling external sound, but do not expect much else. But are they bad?
Hardware Done Right
Noise isolating headphones are definitely not bad. In fact, most on-ear headphones that will find actually do not come with noise cancelation. There are a number of reasons for that as well. In general, on-ear headphones are usually designed for indoor usage in situations you do not have to worry much about outside interference.
Perfect For Outside Usage
But are these on-ear noise isolating headphones not worth it if you plan on using them outside? Absolutely not. A quality pair of on-ear headphones will offer just enough noise isolation for you to not be bothered about the humdrum around you. The best noise isolating headphones share the same unique traits of offering the perfect balance of noise isolation and comfort, so that you are able to listen to your favorite music for long periods of time without being disturbed.
We would definitely not recommend noise isolating headphones if you take a lot of flights or use noisy public transportation options a lot. However, if you only want to shut out background noise in your workplace or for casual walks around the city, then you do not need to invest in noise canceling headphones and a noise isolating pair of headphones should do just fine.
Types of noise-isolating headphones
In-ear headphones: In ear headphones are capable of isolating noise by letting the drivers sit inside your ear holes and snugly fitting your ears to prevent most of the external noise from getting in. Of course, it does not mean that you won’t be able to hear a thing when wearing them, but they definitely get the job done once you turn up the volume a little and listen to some music.
In-ear headphones can get uncomfortable for many users and the last thing you want to do is spend a fortune and end up with uncomfortable headphones. You do get the option of replaceable earbuds with most in-ear designs of varying sizes. However, you should definitely try out a few at a store before finalizing your purchase.
On-ear noise isolating headphones: Most good on-ear noise isolating headphones have some form of noise isolation. Since the earcups fully cover your ears, they prevent too much external noise from getting in.
On-ear type of noise isolating headphones can often get uncomfortable when wearing them for long periods of time. You need to be careful about the design and we definitely recommend heading to a store and checking out what suits you.
Different people have different ear sizes and head sizes, even the best pair of headphones won’t necessarily be comfortable for everyone. The band material, the cup size and material – it all adds up.
You also get access to a variant of on-ear design with around-the-ear headphones. They also fall under the category of on-ear headphones but have larger cups that do not press against your ear. They’re generally well suited for people who find it uncomfortable to sit through long periods of time listening to music wearing headphones.
The Audio-Technica ATH-M50x headphones are legendary in terms of reputation. You do not need to spend a fortune on them and you still get access to some of the best audio money can buy. If you like punchy music with a decent amount of bass, you should definitely pick them up.
Despite being studio monitor the Audio Technica M50x headphones they are quite powerful and offer a colorful sound signature. They are well built and the earcups fit snugly to offer you perfect noise isolation.
- Critically acclaimed sonic performance praised by top audio engineers and pro audio reviewers
- Proprietary 45 millimeter large aperture drivers with rare earth magnets and copper clad aluminum wire voice coils
- Exceptional clarity throughout an extended frequency range, with deep, accurate bass response
The Jaybird X2 offers the perfect mix of noise isolation and the portability of wireless noise canceling headphones. The in-ear design is perfect for cutting out outside noise and offer a great audio experience.
The Bluetooth headphones are perfect for use on-the-go and the massive battery life means that you can listen to music all day long without worrying about charging them.
- Shift premium Bluetooth audio premium sound & warm bass, outperforms most wired headphones
- Signal plus for skip-free music outdoors - use your music device anywhere on your body
- 8 hour super-capacity battery hd
How to Choose Between Noise Canceling vs Noise Isolation Headphones
Technology: There is no powered technology involved when it comes to noise isolation headphones. They make use of seals, ear tips and other ergonomic features to achieve the effect of canceling out outside noise.
However, noise canceling headphones do their own dedicated microphones to pick up ambient noise signals and product ‘anti-noise’ signals to cancel out any external noise.
Both of these methods are not fool proof and you will definitely have some sound entering your ears nonetheless. Quality is also a major factor as in some cases a good pair of noise isolating headphones may outperform a pair of noise canceling headphones that do not offer quality microphones or produce ‘anti-noise’ effectively.
Noise canceling headphones also come with a ton of additional features, specially the wireless ones. You have one tap buttons to disable the microphones so you can listen to what someone has to say to you. You also get access to media playback and call handling buttons which is amazing if you are in crowded transport. You will never have to flip out your fancy phone and risk dropping it ever again.
Price: The sky’s the limit when it comes to pricing. However, if you check the lineup of most popular noise canceling and noise isolating headphones, you’ll notice that noise isolating headphones are relatively cheaper for the most part as all it takes is proper design implementations to cut off noise.
Sound Quality: There is no clear winner here as the right pair of headphones from either category will perform very well. There are some noise isolating headphones that cost a fortune and are priced well above what the best noise isolating headphones would cost.
This is simply because many audiophile noise isolating headphones are designed for listening to audio from a media streaming device with or without a good DAC attached. Sound quality is relative to your use and it all depends on how much you need that extra bit of microphone-assisted noise cancelation from a pair of headphones.
If you plan on listening to music at home where there is little or no disturbance you can even opt for open-back or semi-open back headphones and you won’t go wrong anywhere.
Comfort: On-ear headphones can get quite uncomfortable if you do not know what materials you find comfortable. Some people are fine with leatherette, while others prefer velour while sacrificing a bit of noise isolation.
You ideally want to find the right balance of comfort and noise isolation or cancelation if you want a comfortable experience. Where you use your headphones is a big factor as well. You do not want to pick up headphones with hefty leather earcups if you’re working or traveling in a very hot and humid environment.
Similarly, for noise canceling headphones, weight is a major factor. Since many noise canceling headphones are wireless, you want them to be light enough despite the added controls and built in or external batteries.
In-line Microphone: Nearly all noise isolating headphones do not come with a dedicated microphone if you opt for an on-ear variant. However, if you look at most in-ear options you will find many headphones that are designed for use with laptops, phones and more. They will not only offer you the annoyance-free audio experience you need, but also offer you the ability to talk on the go.
When it comes to noise canceling headphones, nearly all the wireless variants have microphones and call management buttons so you can take calls without needing to pull out your phone.
If you want on-ear headphones with a microphone you can check out gaming headsets that not only offer a decent amount of noise isolation, but also come with detachable or sleeved-in microphones that you can pull out and use for communications.
Last update on 2020-10-21 at 18:46